The Evil Within – Horror Review
Home » Reviews » Game Reviews » The Evil Within – Horror Review

The Evil Within – Horror Review

For those of you who don’t know, the director of The Evil Within is Shinji Mikami, who created the original Biohazard/Resident Evil. This has been at the core of a lot of preview articles in the media, as he not only created the series but revived its fortunes when he assumed directorial duties on Biohazard/Resident Evil 4, regarded by many as the pinnacle of the series (he directed the first, but was supervising producer on 2 and 3, and the other offshoots like Veronica and Zero). These credentials are touted with the greatest of expectations that with The Evil Within he would reinvent ‘Survival Horror’ for the new generation of games consoles.

The Evil Within Review

Format: PS4 (also available on PS3, Xbox One, X360 and PC)

Price: USD 59.99 (Discount available for PS Plus members)

The Evil Within Review
Urgh, my head. Where am I? What happened? And why can’t I see the top and bottom of the screen?

 

There is a series of nods, intentional or otherwise, to the Biohazard legacy. There is a trophy ‘Master of Unlocking,’ a reference to the peculiar line uttered by Barry Burton in RE1. There are a number of sections set in the same type of mountain village with inexplicable medieval European architecture as in RE4. In the very first Resident Evil, there is a sequence when you first happen upon a zombie. You approach from the rear as it munches on a corpse, and it drops a severed head as it turns towards you. That exact sequence is repeated very close to the start of The Evil Within, and unfortunately, this underlines a significant problem: none of this is new. This is not reinventing Survival Horror for next-gen. It’s not even last-gen. Bar the cosmetic uplift of newer hardware, this is little more advanced than PS1 Biohazard, and nowhere near as much fun.

The Evil Within Review
You can see from the symbol in front of the hospital the Umbrella Corporation is up to its old tricks again. OH WAIT NO that’s not the Umbrella logo, it’s a completely and totally different logo. Yes. Totally different. *cough* Wesker *cough*

 

The controls are cumbersome and inexact. It is entirely possible to see a booby trap, edge towards it, and not be able to bring up the context icon to deactivate it. A small shuffle can easily turn into a giant leap forward, straight through the tripwire and back to your last save point. I noted a number of occasions when my character was crouched, I spotted an enemy and attempted to turn back, but pushing back on the L stick simply caused a bizarre hunched moonwalk. And it’s a good job there are invisible walls on many of the ledges in the game otherwise you’d be jumping to your death more than would be tolerable.

The Evil Within Review
A cabin. In the woods. What could possibly go wrong?

 

The control issues are compounded by a peculiar decision to letterbox the display. It’s like playing an imported SCART Super Nintendo on a PAL TV in the old days. The subtitles and chapter headings appear above and below, and it’s not like it improves the viewing area any – in fact it makes it worse, it is sometimes difficult to see, especially when crouched. It’s not like it’s because of new gen widescreen when this is another generation-straddler title.

The Evil Within Review
It’s great how I can deduce the entire history of a set of keys just by picking them up, but I cannot spot people who clearly know what’s going on when they talk about it right in front of me.

 

Story and character are a horror show of the wrong kind. The central police detective character (I think his name is Gene Eric Whiteman) is bland and almost indistinguishable from the protagonist of Murdered Soul Suspect. Conversations are infuriatingly preposterous. For example, in one of the early tramps through the Resident Evil 4 village, some insane occurrence happens, and the doctor you are escorting says “No, Ruvik couldn’t have…” and trails off. Instead of grabbing him by the lapels and shouting “What? WHAT DO YOU KNOW?” into his face, instead officer A. N. Other lets it slide. There are far too many of these leading unfinished sentences by numerous supporting characters that would have any normal person straight into Inquisition mode, never mind a supposed police detective.

The Evil Within Review
Hello, creepy long haired Japanese woman walking on all fours. What a completely original enemy you are.

 

The sins are numerous. There’s the good old “collect 3 of these to open a door!” fully present and correct. Monsters can hit the character through bars, but the favour cannot be returned. The sudden removal of full camera control just to force you to negotiate a corridor filled with mines without being able to see in front of you. Instant death set pieces that see the ‘loading’ screen appear more times than is welcome. Bosses which cannot be killed unless you do X to it Y number of times, then pull a lever. And the monster design itself is uninspired. There’s the clichéd twisty Japanese woman on all fours with long black hair over her eyes straight out of Ringu. Oh and hey, Silent Hill just called and says it wants its barbed wire-wrapped deformities back.

The Evil Within Review
Here we are in a secret underground lab, and oh look, there’s a Tyrant suspended in liquid in a tank. Wait! No, not a Tyrant. Something else, original and definitely next-gen. It’s a…it’s a….quick, start the next chapter without any explanation!

 

It’s hard to avoid the conclusion that the ‘evil within’ referenced in the title is actually the tendency in big games companies to recycle what has worked before. This is indeed evil and needs a definitive stake through its unimaginative heart.

The Evil Within Review

Story A narrative fractured seemingly only to allow more levels to lengthen the game without need of explanation, extrapolated through cringe-inducing dialogue and questions no-one would allow to go unanswered in the circumstances.
Gameplay Controls this clunky are unforgiveable in a new title. Makes the game harder in the most frustrating way possible.
Frustration Very high. Levels are repetitive and made harder through poor control and screen letterboxing.
https://fextralife.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/For-Fans-Only-Game-Icon.png The game for which the “For Genre Fans Only” label was invented. If you like Resident Evil, you’ll like this, because its exactly the same. Others will find it preposterous and tedious in equal measure. For Genre Fans Only

 

About the Author

Comments

8 responses to “The Evil Within – Horror Review”


  1. I didn’t go into The Evil Within expecting a great deal of innovation. In other words, I didn’t expect this video game to reinvent or redefine a genre. I was actually under the impression that it would “bring survival horror back to its roots” rather than reinvent it. It might have a bit too many action and shooter elements in it but I’m glad I added it to my collection. The Evil Within was able to provide me with many hours of rewarding and enjoyable gameplay even if its controls weren’t as tight and responsive to me as they were at E3 2014.

  2. Thanks for the game overview. I’m a big fan of anything horror survival, but I’m extremely picky about my game controls. Knowing that something has issues tells me what to avoid, at least until it turns up for a bargain basement price.

  3. :cheers: There are various kinds of games which are very interesting but it is up to the player which he or she prefer most.

  4. @Waffle – I think that’s the point. A lot of people have fond memories of both original Resi and Silent Hill, and as this is big name territory, a lot of us hoped for a significant title. This isn’t it.

    I wonder if we’re expecting too much based on nostalgia. Many of the sequels and offshoots of both the Biohazard and Silent Hill universes got slated as not living up to the originals. But then look what happens when a major name with significant budget gets to try to build a new chapter in a prime ‘franchise’ world.

    I think Silent Hill: Downpour is better than this, and Murdered Soul Suspect a much more innovative narrative attempt than either, both of which I’d describe as generally accessible. And of course there are much better games in the genre being made.

  5. @AnCapaillMor – thanks for reading. I know this one has quite a lot of attention, so I bought on release and played through the weekend to get posted what I hope is a timely review. I am extremely disappointed. It’s very old style game design and poor controls. And yes, many of those things I listed are definitely also my own bugbears. Better to split the 60 bucks into three and get some smaller, more innovative titles I think.

  6. Thanks for the review. I was also debating if I should buy the game later or not. Seemed to have a mixed feeling of Silent Hill and Resident Evil, so it looked interesting to me :P

  7. Thanks for that dude, was debating would i or won’t i and then heard it was a bit of a mess in the gfx\fps department, that review pretty much listed the things that annoy me in games. so you saved me some cash and i’ll buy you a pint and drink it in your honour.

    Again top marks for the pic captions.

Log in to leave a Comment

Latest from Fextralife