They're the same thing. The Talisman for those incantations calls them Godslayer incants, but all the incantations' descriptions say "incantation of the Godskin Apostles."

Technically the nobles are also "apostles" in the same sense as the 12 apostles of Christ. It states in the lore they are older and more veteran followers of the Gloam-eyed Queen and as such have taken the mantle of Noble but they are still 'apostles' in the very literal sense of the word.

Godslayer incantations would prevent some confusion though, and it just sounds so much more powerful.

He moves to a roadside in the Altus plateau as part of the questline he is associated with, he moves several times throughout the questline, look at his page on the wiki to see where he moves to if you have trouble finding him. Note that many of the books can be given to turtle pope who does not move and thus can be a more reliable teacher.

You can find him In Altus to continue his questline.

That's fair. I prefer the general utility of Faith, but one cannot deny that optimized spells are the king of DPS.

Have you tried manually aiming? I use all of the black flame spells except presence and blade. They may not be bleed, but they can absolutely dunk on anyone dumb enough, granted you���re skilled enough in black flame.

What exactly are you trying to make work? I hope not the black flame effect. Spells generally have always been easy to dodge and percentage based DOT works best on really high health pools i.e. enemies in PVE

Probably the Ash of War on the Godslayer's Greatsword.

The Queen's Black Flame

There is one unused one that the black flame monks use that is a black flame variant of Catch Flame

Also black flame tornado

percentage damage, not sure what percent but it does more damage when the enemy has a higher lotsl health

percentage damage, not sure what percent but it does more damage when the enemy has a higher lotsl health

2-5% of total hp according to the Black Flame page

I think is one of the Erdtree because it's connected to the rune of death, that is basically a shard of the Elden Ring. It's the same effect of the Black Knife ash of war that is directly connected to the rune of death

Black Blade does holy though and these are fire. Honestly they should have just made Black Flames do holy damage possibly since its in the theme of religion.

These are fine as is, frost and bleed need a debuff,

Faith gets buffs and heals. The buffs are incredibly powerful and I love my regen. Godskins get a physical damage negation buff which is very powerful

No they don't need a buff. At best a speed boost because they're slow and some have poor tracking. Black Flame can do some of THE highest damage in the game and I use soft cap faith to shred any boss in any ng+ with minimal effort