you can fail this quest if you don't manage to kill Finn. He fell off the ledge for me and I died before I could get to him again.

Is there any reason not to just fight Finn? Does paying him the 2k provide any benefits other than avoiding the battle?

Having finished the quest by paying him off, it seems like doing that provides absolutely no reward, at least initially. Is there any difference when you complete it by killing Finn?

People saying they get no reward for doing this quest. I got like 20,000 tech scrap.

I paid him the 2.000 scrpas and when I returned to the old lady she had a Mk.IV Little Johny's Forceps for free in her shop. I thought that was the reward.

I think doing her quest DOES benefit you in one way: it opens up her Boss-Weapon function, selling lower tier versions of those bosses you killed with the special kill. For completionists ? Other then that I, too, did get nothing out of it...

I fought him and pushed him off the edge, without thinking went for a ledge jump dive finisher (I don’t even know if that’s a thing, lol!) but I died when I landed, quest failed -.-

if you dont help her finn replaces her in the seaside court.