- Wed Jun 05, 2019 1:35 pm
#16125943
These are cross-posted comments on a wiki page. You can visit the page here. Read Wiki Page
- Wed Jun 05, 2019 1:35 pm
#16125944
i was watching a playthough and this was one of the few fights in these games that made me feel awful for killing one of the bosses
By Anonymous -
By Anonymous -
- Sun Nov 29, 2020 10:56 pm
#16281394
Sif doesn't have a full *** monologue about why you're the bad guy during the fight
By Anonymous -
- Mon Nov 30, 2020 11:47 pm
#16281784
Free her from her misery. She is not really helping anything other than her own conscience and temporary mental support for the people in the valley.
By Anonymous -
- Tue Dec 22, 2020 5:47 pm
#16290208
Emma hit me harder than Sif and Astraea combined. At least with those two you don't have much choice and can't really be blamed.
By Anonymous -
By Anonymous -
By Anonymous -
By Anonymous -
- Thu May 07, 2020 6:04 pm
#16211305
I dunno, i shot her with 60 poison arrows and she never got poisoned. She still took good damage from them though.
By Anonymous -
- Mon Jan 04, 2021 4:04 pm
#16295082
Went back in fractured mode with PWWT to fight Black Phantom Garl and he just stood there with his shield up. It took several shots of fire, as each shot only did 36 dmg in NG+, and he only tried to heal twice, which was negligible.
By Anonymous -
- Thu Jan 07, 2021 6:40 pm
#16296539
People be like “ayo this fight sad” then there’s me like “no stupid. The filthy women literally says the valley of defilement went to garbage when she arrived. Furthermore she’s chosen to become an arch demon, feeding the old one souls.”
By Anonymous -
- Sun Jan 24, 2021 9:42 pm
#16302342
Rule #1 of Soulsborne: every bad thing is secretly good, every good thing is secretly bad. Astraea was a demon, but it reveals that demons and gods aren't at all different except in how they are percieved by the collective. Astraea provided a haven for those who had nowhere left to turn (which is why the valley became "defiled"). Even Selen remarks how despite its filth, the valley and its inhabitants are pure of soul—creatures you can't help but pity, that don't desire anything but to live in peace. They merely attack because you prove to be a threat to their way of life.
Second thing—archdemons don't provide souls to the Old One until they reunite with it. That means you. You're the one destined to feed it the souls of the archdemons and their followers. Archdemons don't necessarily serve the Old One, least of all Astraea, whose faith in god instilled in her an urge to protect the souls of the defiled ones, having been abandoned to be devoured by the Old One in the first place.
Second thing—archdemons don't provide souls to the Old One until they reunite with it. That means you. You're the one destined to feed it the souls of the archdemons and their followers. Archdemons don't necessarily serve the Old One, least of all Astraea, whose faith in god instilled in her an urge to protect the souls of the defiled ones, having been abandoned to be devoured by the Old One in the first place.
By Anonymous -
- Wed Jul 21, 2021 9:36 pm
#16357999
"Rule #1 of Soulsborne: every bad thing is secretly good, every good thing is secretly bad. "
No ir isn't. You pulled that out of your ***. Like the rest of your speculation.
No ir isn't. You pulled that out of your ***. Like the rest of your speculation.
By Anonymous -
- Sun Dec 19, 2021 4:30 pm
#16395256
astrea tried to suck the corruption into her to free the others, but it didn't work.
By Anonymous -
- Sun Feb 06, 2022 1:43 pm
#16408298
Ah yes, the same Filthy Woman who basically says "Dudes used to fancy me till Astraea came along"
By Anonymous -
- Wed Jul 27, 2022 11:08 pm
#16745610
"No ir isn't. You pulled that out of your ***. Like the rest of your speculation." It's completely true lmao. Having nuanced bosses with sad backstories is like the first thing most people think about when they relate lore to gameplay.
By Anonymous -
- Sun Nov 06, 2022 6:56 am
#16794356
You take the filthy woman* as a reliable source. Who's the stupid one here?
By Anonymous -
By Anonymous -
By Anonymous -
