Infused this with Dark and somehow it does even less damage than a Dark Battleaxe, even with Dark Weapon. Is it supposed to be like that?

I have trouble understanding why people would use this in a build. It's found so late game that by the time you get to it you will have a maxed out weapon

It's ridiculous. I agree with the other comment. I was told by countless people online that the silverblack weapons were ideal for hexer builds or hybrids, now I dunno whether or not they got nerfed, but they are completely outclassed by other weapons. The dark halberd, or bandit axe, or winged spear, I could go on and on, totally out damages these weapons, and have better movesets. I've tried moving my stats around thinking maybe my build was off, but no, there are FAR better weapons to use on a dark hexer build. Unless you are doing like a grave warden CP build or something like that for cosmetic purposes only. If you are playing SotFS you can far unlimited dark stones very early, I highly recommend toying around with dark infusions on other weapons before investing your early game chunks into the spear and the sickle is a late game weapon. Darkdrift on the other hand.

Fish Hook

A cooler looking hand axe with higher requirements. I much prefer the spear for dark builds.

This got 331 base dark damage on 40/40 build. One of the best dark damages you can get for the weight! I dont know why people are crying in the comments.

I know it's a lot, the hair, the bod, when you're staring at a demigod!