He said perhaps

It's conjecture,*****head. Learn to *****ing read.

More likely Stables.

Then I should be allowed to add a line that says Artorias was homosexual in his strategy section if unsubstantiated guesses are free game now. Useless head-cannon in the location section is still useless if there's nothing to support it or assist the reader.

So true

Giant Blacksmith wont ask for anything , he can do it without the embers

The people on this wiki seem almost toxic he was asking s simple question no need for all the down voting