Comments posted to our Bloodborne Wiki
By Anonymous
#15827566
Just a little theory as i just noticed the Red Jeweled Brooch looks exactly the same (if not very similar) to the necklace you'll wear with the Knight's Garb. How did she get it? Are they the same?
By Anonymous
#15827567
Could be an older design or for a different type o knight or garrison I bet gacione and viola met in a fight and fell in love while tearing off a monsters head together
By Anonymous
#15827568
Her father is Gascoigne isn't he? Then the brooch is gifted from when he was a night to the mother?
By Anonymous
#15992059
Her father was the man you killed to get the brooch. Her father is a hunter knight like you. That's where her mother got the brooch.
By Anonymous
#15827569
Yeah, she's crying, I hope she will calm down and give me something in return ;D
By Anonymous
#15827570
I think i some how bugged the quest. I had told the woman by the dogs to go to the Cathedral Ward and ran straight to the girl and told her the same. I can see the old woman but the little girl isn't there, and now her window is empty when i visit her.
By Anonymous
#15827571
I recommend using the broch, equipping the item on the weapon, telling the kid about the the problem, then going back to fight a very tough foe in the cemetery where you found the Broch.
By Anonymous
#15827572
this is how i did it; Cleric beast Talked to her, got the music box Gascoigne Find the Brooch up the stairs and drop down off the ledge Back to her, games asked if I would give it back, I chose no Then it asked if she can go to the chapel or the clinic, said chapel
By Anonymous
#15827574
If you send her to the clinic I don't think you get the bloody ribbon and without that you can't get the regular either
By Anonymous
#15827575
I found her dead at the bottom of the ladder next to her house.
By Anonymous
#15827576
Use the music box on Father Gascoigne.
By Anonymous
#15827577
That's because she gets eaten by the pig in the sewer thing. If you kill it, it drops her ribbon.
By Anonymous
#15827578
Said foe only appears if you trigger that side quest with the raven-clad hunter at the waterway.
By Anonymous
#15827579
I think i some how bugged the quest. I had told the woman by the dogs to go to the Cathedral Ward and ran straight to the girl and told her the same. I can see the old woman but the little girl isn't there, and now her window is empty when i visit her.
By Anonymous
#15827580
Technically she'll survive if you send her to the clinic, I mean she'll be an alien, but alive nonetheless.
By Anonymous
#15827581
Viola is not the daughter, it's the wife.
By Anonymous
#15827582
the bullet points are totally wrong in all almost every way. but i can't edit them
By Anonymous
#16014906
When I gave the girl the jewel she cried and it made me feel so bad, I don’t think ill recover from that ;_;
By Anonymous
#16232056
Thats not even the worst part....
By Anonymous
#16226814
You find it near Father Gascoigne...and the girl in the window said a) her mother wears the brooch, and b) the music box calms her father when he forgets who they are...Father Gascoigne goes into a terrifying, inhuman Beast Mode...Is Father Gascoigne the girl's father???
By Anonymous
#16227680
Yes.
By Anonymous
#16360909
bruuuuuuhhh
By PontiffGundyr
Posts
#16732029
I mean you deducted all that using context clues but still couldn’t figure out the answer…
By Anonymous
#16755810
His name is right there on the music box
By Anonymous
#16360910
WHO CARES ABOUT THE LITTLE GIRL ITS A BLOOD GEM IM GONNA GET IT NO MATTER WHAT SCREW YOU SMAL CHILD !!!!!!
By Anonymous
#16797775
Saw a theory that there was no second daughter, and that the one who shows up after is an impostor, similar to Iosefka. When you give her the red ribbon she says “What a perfect ribbon… and now it’s mine”. Doesn’t exactly sound like a sisterly thing to say