Comments posted to our Bloodborne Wiki
By Anonymous
#15812012
In a lower hinter tomb dungeon. A bath was behind a door selling them even though I didn't have the badge.
By Anonymous
#15812013
They actually do some damage but are useless against actual players in pvp. If they have an antidote which is really common, landing 3 hits with a knife is really not worth the risk for dealing another 5 damage with poison. Use them on NPC hunters instead they absolutely make the toughest fights a breeze
By Anonymous
#15812014
Are they as useful in ng+ vs hunters? or completely useless?
By Anonymous
#15812015
i got like 15-20 knives in the cathedral ward just before you enter the area with the 2 cathedral giants... i think it was to the left... not sure though!
By Anonymous
#15812016
So poison knives don't work on Henryk anymore? Henryk is immune to poison now? I landed a bunch of poison knives into him despite his dodging, saw the squish and the first tick of damage, but nothing happens and I used to only throw ONE to see the effects begin to work. Just tried poison knives on another character in newgame plus to cheese that npc cannibal dude in the forbidden woods and for some reason the poison knives still worked fine. Since some people might want Eileen alive on their playthrough, keep in mind that poison might not work at all anymore for Henryk so be prepared to beat him up the old fashioned way.
By Anonymous
#15812017
how did people find out the prices for these before beating rom/entering cathedral ward? to GET the eye watcher badge you need to get to Yahar'Gul, which is acessible after beating rom only (I don't mean the Hypogeum Gaol, you cant get upper cathedral ward key there).
By Anonymous
#15812018
You can get them from a bath messenger in the chalice dungeon before beating room or entering cathedral ward.
By Anonymous
#15812019
How would the tonsil stone ever get you to yahar gul?
By Anonymous
#15812020
This. Was just thinking this. This wiki really needs better moderation.
By Anonymous
#15812021
It says the price at NG+ is 2800... Doubt that is how they found out
By Anonymous
#15812022
Ng+ duh
By Anonymous
#15812023
Good point
By Anonymous
#15812024
I'd assume someone managed to mod the game so they had the cosmic eye watcher badge early, that or found them in a chalice dungeon
By Anonymous
#15812025
U can get to the yahar gul using the tinsil stone before defeating rom
By Anonymous
#15812026
I was able to purchase these for 1900 echoes or so in the third layer of Lower Hintertomb Same Bath messenger from which the Sinister Hintertomb Root Chalice is aquired
By Anonymous
#15812027
In Pthumeru Root Chalice (Depth: 1), can appears bath messengers that sell at the price of about 900 echoes. I still have not killed Amelia.
By Anonymous
#15812028
Should have mentioned that that at that point I did not have (and still dont have) the Cosmic Eye watcher badge for that character Is it possible that all bath messengers in dungeons sell certain badge specific items? Or only certain ones?
By Anonymous
#15812029
....get the cosmic eye watcher badge
By Anonymous
#15812030
These knives have a D scaling in strength. Is anyone aware of the skill scaling of this item?
By Anonymous
#15962512
with item Discovery 226, 1 in 9 pthumerian undead will drop a poison knife (tested in central pthumerian chalice)
By Figlio_di_notte
#15962516
with item discovering 226, 1 in 6 pthumerian undead will drop poison knife (tested on central pthumerian chalice)
By Anonymous
#16019928
my thoughts, what is the items poison add, gems add a specific amount of poison, so how much poison add do the poison knives deal per hit, does it scale, vary by enemy type or does every enemy have they're set resistance to the poison knives?