Comments posted to our Bloodborne Wiki
1 
 
Avatar

FextraBot

Town Crier
Joined: Tue Nov 12, 2013 6:27 am
Souls: 0.00
Posts: 11993
Reputation: 1
These are cross-posted comments on a wiki page. You can visit the page here.  Read Wiki Page

I went and talk to them in central Yarnham, then proceeded to kill the Clerical Beast, Gascoigne, and the Blood-starved Beast.
Then I totally forgot about her and killed Amelia. Now i can't find her in the cathedral ward, does it mean I can't achieve the first questline or can I trigger it in some other way ? I rushed to the Tomb of Oedon but found nothing there.
I didn't!
if you killed amelia before killing henryk then you have failed her quest.
Confirmed to be false, I killed Amelia, then killed henryk after. Perhaps missing her when she first spawns for the henryk quest or ignoring her after your character approaches her or ignoring henryk for too long will end the quest line as they settle the fight w out your character.
When I found her first, I talked to her and tried to kill her, but failed. Now I heard about this quest I wonder if I could still complete the quest?
Not possible, if she becomes hostile you stop her quest line. You can complete it on a ng+ or new character if you really want it.
+1.
+1.
I followed the steps to a tee. I did everything and killed that cheap katana wielding weeb, she gives me her stupid badge but she won't let me join the guild or give me the gesture no matter how many times I talked to her. She kept talking about closing her eyes and "getting some rest". I should've killed that *****ing bird at first glance. I left and now she's gone, has to be a glitch.
Same, went back with the rune equipped and only a blood stain, WTH happened
You get the gesture by taking to get before entering the cathedral. You "join" the covenant by equipping the rune, that's all. After you kill the last hunter and reload or leave age disappears
Avatar

Rakuyo

Caffeinated
Guardian

Joined: Wed Feb 03, 2016 6:35 am
Souls: 55.00
Bank: 47,565.00
Posts: 985
Reputation: 19
Wiki Edits: 10990
Language children...
i dunno about the gesture, but if you wear the rune, youre in the covenant
You get the gesture by taking to get before entering the cathedral. You "join" the covenant by equipping the rune, that's all. After you kill the last hunter and reload or leave age disappears
What if she died during the henryk fight? I fought him and died but when i came back she died before i could help her fight and after i beat him i found the crow hunter badge. Does this mean i wont see her again?
yup
On NG++ and I can't seem to find her in either Cathedral Ward or Central? I'm on Shadows right now but didn't kill the Witches of Hemwick.
Doesn't she also say "The hunt makes hunters mad" when she kills you?

Fiddlesticks

Addicted
First Warden

Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2016 8:00 am
Souls: 715.00
Posts: 184
Reputation: 0
Wiki Edits: 111
possible glitch, did you visit her in central before advancing to the night stage of the game?
Npc dialogue changes during diff moon phases w everyone going batty during the bloodmoon
I just kicked Paarl's dark beast ***. She appeared after I opened two of the gates towards cathedral ward from the large graveyard where you needed to unlock with the church hunter emblem(the one for 10k blood echoes).
"Killing the Witch of Hemwick before speaking to her in Cathedral Ward also causes her to disappear from this location."

I killed Amelia, then the witches, and she was still in that location, and I hadn't spoken to her. This needs more confirmation, as in my experience, it's not true.
i killed vicar, witch and paarl before talking to her... misinformation much?
I also killed Paarl before opening the two gates, she appeared anyway
I missed her second encounter by cathedral ward but while farming around I saw her fighting Henryk at the tomb of oedon and I was basically able to help her. Since I didn't talk to her at for step 2, will she turn hostile? So far she just stays at the tomb of oedon telling me to keep my hands clean...
False, just killed the witch and vicar before talking to Eileen in the cathedral location and she was there
so, I try to kill her the first time, but failed (trying to make her fall off). Now I need some ideas on what I can do because she is waiting for me!!!! PLEASE HELP NEED THAT BADGE SO BAD!!
Perhaps you should have done the quest line :p
#HunterofHunter4lyf

Real talk, the only weakness the Blades of Mercy have in my experience is range. I've gotten up in people's faces and completely destroyed them before they can fight back, but if they can out-range me it becomes a bit more difficult.
Try visceral, Eileen is aggressive and if timed well, you can parry her. Takes practice. The questline wud be a cooler way to get her stuff bro. You get extra goodies like the gear of henryk
Can u do her quest line on new game + even after you killed her in the first run?
There's no easy way to go about it mate, took me about 30 tries but you'll get it eventually
On two playthroughs I've talked to her in her first location but she seems to never be outside the Cathedral Ward so I couldn't talk to her to get the dialogue about the Tomb of Oedon and then BOTH times I've passed through the Tomb of Oedon Henryk attacked and on my current playthrough this has really messed up my plan to KEEP HER ALIVE! This shouldn't have triggered without speaking outside the Cathedral Ward right?
Might be that you missed her, she will soon rush in and help you fight henryk if so. Did you attack henryk?
Might be that you missed her, she will soon rush in and help you fight henryk if so. Did you attack henryk?

Fiddlesticks

Addicted
First Warden

Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2016 8:00 am
Souls: 715.00
Posts: 184
Reputation: 0
Wiki Edits: 111
Not sure, but I think its advancing the time to night after interacting with the skull of lawrence, that makes her spawn to the cathedral ward. After all advancing to the next phase, the blood moon, triggers her final quest. It is possible to trigger Henryk with out speaking to her. If she moves to catherdral ward, then that means Henryk is there. I hope you rushed back and fought henryk, just fight defensively then she will appear and help out after a few seconds. Dont hit her too much during the fight or she will be hostile after. Simply shoot henryk if he stunlocks her or attack henryk from behind while she wails on him in front. Lots of better goodies to collect even if you miss the questline, there is also ng+
You need to unlock a certain gate in cathedral ward to make her spawn. But if henryk already spawned, she might be there. Though engaging henryk will make her fight him. Eileens chances of winning alone aren't too good.
her questline does provide good stuff, but its more suited to a skill arcane build. Lots of other neat stuff.