Comments posted to our Bloodborne Wiki
By Anonymous
#16228148
Do you have to get all of them on the same character to get the trophy?
By Anonymous
#16228448
That’s how every one of their games work
By Anonymous
#16204259
Madaras Whistle requires the dlc so it does not count for the trophy
By Anonymous
#16205135
You can kill the covernant npc that the npc how gives the hunter tool will appear to you
By Anonymous
#16253710
I got it without the dlc
By Anonymous
#16315409
Dead wrong.
By Anonymous
#16326844
The whistle doesn't require the dlc, it was however added with an update that addrd the dlc, so as far as the trophy is concerned, it is not a base game item
By Anonymous
#16194444
Currently doing a hunter tool (no weapons) build. My recommendations for absolute must grabs are augur and executioner. Augur is solid damage as well as is able to backstab for SUBLIME damage. Executioner is decent long range damage to function as a (kind of pricey) better pebble (Yes, I played the whole game until forbidden woods fist only)
By Anonymous
#16200125
Auger can also parry
By Anonymous
#16203531
You could have just used the recently discovered forbidden wood skip. It would have given you direct access to forbidden wood and fast access to cainhurst.
By Anonymous
#16268641
*sniff* *sniff* Am I the only one who smells some... hmm.... specifically *******
By Anonymous
#16346187
Yes we sure believe u did that
By Anonymous
#16371532
Wrong use of sublime, but ok
By Anonymous
#16148921
Do i have to re-get all of them if i missed one and went into new game + ?
By Anonymous
#16149467
No
By Anonymous
#16156675
yes
By Anonymous
#16163676
You only have to collect the ones you missed during ng+. Unlike other unique items, you can get multiple copies of each hunter tool through the ng cycles.
By Anonymous
#16140241
I don’t have Madaras Whistle but I still got the trophy woo
By Anonymous
#16193353
madaras whistle was introduced in the update that came with the dlc, so it wouldn't count towards that achievement.
By Anonymous
#16126629
The dlc's hunter tools does not count for the trophy right?
By Anonymous
#16128276
No they do not, just like the other games in the franchise
By Anonymous
#16096469
I have all these and the trophy didn't unlock. Any insight?
By Anonymous
#16098549
Either you missed one, did it offline, or something shady.
By Anedime
Posts
#16105856
You missed one fam, go through the list again. Doing offline doesn't matter, trophies are handled locally, not by game servers, and the only way wouldn't get the trophy is if you used a save editor to give yourself all of them because the way the game is handled is it checks whether you have all of them or not every time you pick up one, until you have all of them. So if you gave yourself all of them with a save editor, the game would skip that check and never award you the trophy.
By Anonymous
#16131485
That trophy seems weird; I got it without the Madara's Whistle
By Anonymous
#16138733
Madara's whistle is a DLC item, thus not needed for the trophy. :)
By Anonymous
#16144815
You need to have them all in your inventory at the same time.
By Anonymous
#16154453
I have the same issue and there's no way I used a save editor. I declare this trophy to be bugged.
By Anonymous
#16049173
Man, I was thinking it would have been awesome to get something like the hand that the rite keepers use to summon fireballs. All these pyromancer enemies in the game, and we never once learn how to summon fire. All we get are lame molotovs.
By Anonymous
#16030020
An easy way to get the whistle is Afro Valtr and have him follow as you take the elevator down and he will follow to his death the same goes for the hunter when you reload the area
By Anonymous
#16317869
Thanks for the mental image of Valtr with an afro
By Anonymous
#16028881
HOW CAN THIS GAME NOT GET PS4 PRO SUPPORT!!! IT IS LIKE KILLING AN ARTFORM!!! THE ALIASING IS TERRIBLE!!! If this HAD SUPPORT 4k native full stop; or 1440p w BETTER ANTI-ALIASING and betting frame rate would be FINE!! NO other graphical upgrades needed; just AA and resolution; and maybe FPS.. The game aesthetically is a WORK OF ART; ruined by the technology used.. SUPPORT PS4 PRO FROM SOFTWARE!!! YOU HAVE THE TIME!!!!!
By Anonymous
#16043699
You realize this was a released very early in the ps4 lifespan (I don't think launch?) so it was well before the pro.
By Anonymous
#16045680
IT'S AN OLD GAME. Miyazaki has bigger things to build. JUST TAKE IT.
By Anonymous
#16086181
Calm down ya *****in nerd. This game came out well before the pro.
By Zestyboi
Posts
#16135266
This is the wiki, go to reddit or other forums
By Anonymous
#16136457
REEEEEEEEEE
By Anonymous
#16169069
stfu *, this is why your mother hates you and your dad beats you
By Anonymous
#16297202
The funny thing is that it actually runs a lot smoother on pro
By Anonymous
#16392131
Dude I'm picky about my framerate and fidelity too but **** off... the game compensates handsomely with it's gameplay, just play it