Comments posted to our Bloodborne Wiki
By Anonymous
#15807235
It's not that she becomes grateful and nice towards you. She just snapped and lost her mind, now she thinks you're her dead(?) daughter. The daughter probably died from frenzy.
By Anonymous
#15807236
I don't have any other NPC in the church except that creepy thing that told in the first place about the safe place is it possible it killed her?
By Anonymous
#15807237
I don't have any other NPC in the church except that creepy thing that told in the first place about the safe place is it possible it killed her?
By Anonymous
#15807238
Or son, I guess. Depending on your MC
User avatar
By casanoffi
Posts Avatar
#15807239
I already killed Cleric Beast, Father Cascoigne and Bloodstarved Beast - and then I spoke to the Old Lady.
By Anonymous
#15807240
I confirm that she is very kind after beating Cleric Beast, Father Gascoigne, Witch of Hemwick, Blood-Starved Beast, Darkbeast Paarl, Vicar Amelia and Shadow of Yharnam (Patch 1.05).
By Anonymous
#15807241
She was kind to me after I had beaten only Cleric Beast, Father Gascoigne, and Vicar Amelia.
By Anonymous
#15807242
She actually seems to be kind after beating only father gacsoigne, vicar amelia, and shadow of yharnam
By Anonymous
#15807243
not sure if the trigger is the number of bosses, having spoken to her just before and just after having killed the shadow of yharnam, that's when the dialogue change triggered for me. (Cleric Beast, Gascoigne, BSB, Amelia, Amygdala, Witch of Hemwick I have also killed so it might be number of bosses also)
By Anonymous
#15807244
Same for me. I also beat those two hunters to the right of the cathedral, and the one with Eileen in the same area Gascoigne's fight was, but those are the only 3 bosses I've killed and she's turned nice. Maybe it happens when you use the tonsil stone to get Amygdala to transport you to the lecture hall? That's when I noticed it anyway. Other things of note I did around that time were bring in the ***** and the skeptic to the chapel, and go through part of the forbidden woods up until you meet the legion guy.
By Anonymous
#16380625
Its obviously because you trigger the next phase of the game by dying to those homo bag totting hoodie guys
By Anonymous
#15807245
If you kill her, she says a dialogue "It was your... Father's blood" Is that new? Before i dont remember her saying that when killing her.
By Anonymous
#15807246
Correction: "It's... Your father's blood."
By Anonymous
#15807247
The sky has turned dark, I have beaten the shadows of yharnim bossfight and lit the lantern by byrgenwoth and immediately teleported back to the hunter's dream, she gives me sedatives even though I haven't even enterd the academy.
By Anonymous
#15807248
The first time I noticed her being friendly was after I killed Logarius and talked to the queen and I've pretty much followed this wiki's progress route so I think Logarius would have been the 7th boss I killed.
By Anonymous
#15807249
I may have narrowed it down a bit. For me she became 'motherly' after unlocking the lamp for the Forbidden Woods, and unlocking the shortcut from the area with a bunch of snakes. Not sure if the shortcut is necessary, as I didn't talk to her between unlocking the lamp, and unlocking the shortcut
By SirensVoice
Posts Avatar
#15807250
I used the wall jump early in the game and noticed that the man that gives you the Tonsil Stone and the Lonely Old Woman switch locations. She now is afraid of me and constantly tells me to leave her alone. Wondering if I can still send her to the chapel?
By Anonymous
#15807251
what is the wall jump??
By Anonymous
#15807252
Me also
By Anonymous
#15807253
That strange creature sitting on the floor, or whatever it was, had me fooled. I immediately assumed it was a creature and struck it, killing it instantly. It wasn't until after when he said, "I just wanted to help..." that I realized I had possibly made an error. After having watched this, I realize there are all these twists and turns to the story. Honestly, it is aggravating because none of it is direct. When I arrived at the Suspicious Beggar, I did not even have the option of telling him to go anywhere, which is likely a result of these multiple NPC mistakes. Incredibly lame.
By Anonymous
#15807254
Game is not lame, its just people are too dumb to think before strike. You got cut-scene upon entering Chapel and notice there someone sitting next to you, its obvious non hostile. How could you attack him when he did nothing.harm.
By Anonymous
#15807255
I can't lock on to him
By Anonymous
#15807256
C'mon man, you can't lock on to non enemies.
By Anonymous
#15807257
It's your fault for killing the NPC, the game didn't tell you he was an enemy.
By Vicious007
Posts
#15807258
Good thing you need to play through the game at least 3 times then, huh?
By Anonymous
#15807259
You can't lock onto him, and I charged a Kirkhammer sword thrust and hit him, he took no damage and simply got startled, so I have no idea how you managed to kill him without knowing.
By Anonymous
#15807260
And this is the magic of the Souls Series. Very little is handed to you.
By Anonymous
#15807261
You can lock on him at least i can do it
By Anonymous
#15807262
LOL. I almost did the same thing until I startled her after I struck her. Then I realized she was an npc.
By Anonymous
#16130544
It isn't that lame. The game wants you to think before you act. Not be primitive and kill everyone without a thought
By Anonymous
#16130545
Not lame at all. Just rewarding subtle actions and reflection instead of primitive beastlike gut reactions. Pretty great if you ask me :)
By Anonymous
#15807263
I have a theory the amygdala grabbed her while she was possibly searching the corpse of the man wearing the hunter set, that or the saw the amygdla, went mad, and killed herself.
By Anonymous
#15807264
She not the
By Anonymous
#15807265
When you kill her she says "it's your fathers blood" and drops one sedative.
By Anonymous
#15807266
I killed her on my 2nd playthrough having the Corruption rune equipped. She said the same thing, and gave me a Blood Dreg.
By Anonymous
#15807267
Ay you queers didn't read the sedative description. The sedatives are made of blood. What she means is that the blood that makes the sedatives are her husband's blood
By Anonymous
#15807268
probably means that because she thinks we are her child, as if we are like her husband
By Anonymous
#15807269
" What she means is that the blood that makes the sedatives are her husband's blood" Makes sense, as she's gone senile and thinks you're her child.
By Anonymous
#15807270
how wude :|
By Anonymous
#15807271
Really no one else had this idea she could be saying you ( or more accurately her kid who she thinks you are) is violent or suceptible to frenzy because the in got it from their dad
By Anonymous
#15807272
When she says "it's your father's blood" she likely says to insult the player, sort of like saying "I killed your father and you drank his blood"