2018 Fexy Game Awards – Our GOTY 2018

2018 Fexy Game Awards – Our GOTY 2018

Last updated on July 3rd, 2021

Welcome to Fextralife’s yearly GOTY awards! The Fexy Awards feature our favorite games of the last 12 months, but with a different twist than most sites: We focus on the games our community loves! These are the winners of this year’s game awards.

Fexy Awards: The Best Games of 2018


Best Storytelling: Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2 was the blockbuster gamers expected, and we certainly enjoyed it as you can see in our RDR2 Review. Whilst the game starts out slow and has some drawbacks, we felt truly transported to a Wild West story, where both allies and enemies had convincing motivations delivered through exceptional voice acting. A compelling music score only adds to a 60 hour buildup to a magnificent finale that will not disappoint.


Red Dead Redemption 2 takes Storyteller of the Year 2018


Best Gameplay: Dead Cells

Dead Cells had been in early access for quite a while, but we reserved final judgement until the full game was out, and we are so glad we did. In a year featuring remasters, relaunches and sequels, this indie title managed to outdo AAA studios in the gameplay factor by delivering an undeniably fun experience that extended beyond the player to be shared in streaming. The excellent Twitch integration of the title meant that streamers and their audience could join in to battle with and against each other, complimenting the dynamic gameplay of this roguelike. Whether you were streaming, participating in an audience, or simply playing by yourself, Dead Cells is simply gameplay fun.


Dead Cells proved that gameplay is king, and Indies can make budget FUN


Best Visual & Audio: God of War

Whilst Red Dead Redemption 2 has a fantastic score and great voice acting, we feel that it was God of War that pushed the boundaries of what audiovisuals can do. Delivering a fantastic rendering of norse mythology with a unique stylistic approach, Sony Santa Monica surpassed our expectations even as we prepare for more Last of Us 2. The world of Kratos is detailed, mystical and interesting, with exceptional performance at 4k, which is integral to an action-adventure title. The voice acting gave a superb delivery, convincingly refocusing the game’s mythos, and the excellent music score delivered a fantastic background for our explorations.

god of war arteus kratos

God of War delivers fantastically smooth 4k graphics with a compelling world design, supported by an incredible track


Best Multiplayer: Dark Souls Remastered

Fextralife users were thrilled to hear that Dark Souls Remastered would introduce revamped multiplayer features, and it was the most MP fun we had all year. Whilst other titles may do multiplayer features more extensively or impressively, the allure of a good Coop / PVP sessions of souls is simply too much for us to pass up and loved the nostalgia trip. Whether you’re looking for help with a difficult Boss, or simply want to participate in Forest Covenant griefing, Souls players from all incarnations of Lordran converged to make it happen via pvp events, tournaments and jolly cooperation.

Dark Souls Remastered

Dark Souls’ Multiplayer formula is timeless, but the improvements from sequels re-ignited our passion.


Best Value: Monster Hunter World

Monster Hunter World takes our Best Value award by virtue of its commitment to a stream of wonderful, free DLC and Events. The game clocks in over 50 hours of basic story mode, which unlocks at least another 50 hours of advanced hunting, and is then buffed up by weekly event quests, seasonal Festivals, and the introduction of new special monsters and harder versions of previously known monsters – all for free. In a world plagued with microtransactions and cut content, the Capcom team kept true to its “Play to Win” word and we have gotten hundreds of hours from our launch-day 60 USD. The game is due its first paid expansion Fall next year, at which point you might even be able to get this bundled for an ever better value pack!


Thousands of Weapons, Hundreds of Armor Pieces, Dozens of skills, Decorations and Monsters to face – amazing value for MHW


Best Soulslike: Death’s Gambit

Souls has become its own sub-genre of action-RPG, and this year the game that we felt gave us the most original yet close experience was Death’s Gambit. Bringing pixel art execution to the souls formula is not as easy as one might think, but the intricate systems of Death’s Gambit and the slow but engaging introduction of its story and characters rang all the right bells. Whilst the game didn’t deliver on all of our expectations, the developers have announced an incoming free DLC that will address player concerns and adds content such as new bosses, weapons, and main world improvements. We really enjoyed this title so we’re looking forward to it!

Cinematic Trailer Death's Gambit 01

Soulslike is more of a “feel” than a tangible, and Death’s Gambit scratched that itch


Best DLC: Elder Scrolls Online: Summerset

Elder Scrolls Online launched a gorgeous expansion this year, giving players access to the Altmer island of Summerset. Besides providing a truly gorgeous backdrop with an interesting story, the expansion brought the long-awaited Jewelry Crafting. Other changes to the game that affect all players (for free) included the introduction of Jewelry Traits, Daily Login Rewards, Two-Handed weapons started counting as 2 set pieces, PvP improvements and the ability to gift Crown Store items. To top it all off, the ESO team has since deployed several events that reward free mounts and and even an amazing house for players who participate in them.


Elder Scrolls Online: Summerset brings the right combination of paid expansion and free improvements that we want to see with a DLC


Best Traditional RPG: Pillars of Eternity 2: Deadfire

Fextralife is all about RPGs, and this year we really enjoyed getting to play Pillars of Eternity 2: Deadfire. With the second installment in a franchise of what many players consider the spiritual successor to Baldur’s Gate, Pillars of Eternity 2 surpassed our expectations. Obsidian built upon the success of the first title, and added a depth of character customization never before seen in gaming. With endless possible combinations of Classes and Subclasses, the replay value of PoE 2 is nearly endless, and Obsidian keeps on cranking out the content. With 11 new Subclasses added just a few weeks ago, it is likely that no one player will ever be able to experience all of the possible combinations.

Pillars of Eternity 2 Soulbound Weapons 01

Pillars of Eternity 2: Deadfire delivers on its promise to stay true to CRPG core and gave us so many character customization options we fear we might never stop making builds


Best Surprise: Assassin’s Creed: Odyssey

Assassin’s Creed Odyssey was not a title we were expecting to get hooked on, but we are certainly very glad we did. Whilst we enjoyed the original installment of the AC series, we felt things had gone downhill with yearly production, and we are extremely happy to see a change in direction towards RPG elements and immersion. AC: Odyssey surprised us by delivering a compelling rendition of Ancient Greece wrapped up in excellent gameplay, fantastic graphics and considerable scale. We cannot wait to see what Dragon Age’s boss Mike Laidlaw brings as he joins the AC: Odyssey ubisoft studio. A world like Odyssey for a fully immersive, decision-based and customization-friendly RPG would be the dream.

Assassasin's Creed Odyssey Hunter 01

Character Choice, Skill Trees, Equipment customization – Assassin’s Creed is becoming an RPG and we love it


Game of the Year: Monster Hunter World

Capcom finally brought its unique hunting title to the Playstation 4 and Xbox One, and PC. Many feared that the game might not translate well to a more mainstream audience, or that it would over-simplify and do away with the complexity that has kept fans glued to the series for years. These fears turned out to not have been necessary, as the game delivered a precise mix of oldschool and new mechanics that are enticing to vets and mainstream alike.

Monster Hunter World is the perfect installment to introduce newcomers to the Monster Hunter universe, providing 4k resolution, excellent performance, and a constant stream of fresh content so that you might not even think about having done it all. Doing away with lengthy explanations that presented a barrier to entry, Monster Hunter World instead provides layers of complexity that players can discover and master at their own leisure. As we played, we discovered new and interesting aspects and mechanics, tried new techniques, and overall enjoyed the social and gameplay aspects of the game. Large, Powerful and Impressive, Monster Hunter World takes on favorites such as RDR 2 and GOW and comes ahead simply by virtue of its uniqueness and commitment to delivery.


Monster Hunter World has it all: Awesome graphics, Character Customization and Development, Great Gameplay, Good Multiplayer, and Cats.

2018 Fexy Community Awards

Forum / Discord Member: MotherEternity

Our Forums and Discord boast 75k and 25k members, so picking a member of the year is always a challenge. This year, however, we must highlight the consistant and wonderful contributions of community volunteer moderator MotherEternity. Juggling kids, family life and a full time job, ME still finds the time to help those in need in several games, respond to forum threads, and keep our site spam free.

Wiki Contributor: Xsanf

As always, this is a very difficult choice as there are thousands of editors constantly contributing to our 100+ wikis. Xsanf wins the year for his dedicated contributions to the Pillars of Eternity 2 Wiki, where he has not only found and fixed mistakes, but sourced and placed images, created pages, and contributed to the overall well-being of this wonderful title. Special mentions to DKS3 wiki contributors Conjuri12 and MHW contributor BlueWhiteNexus, who have been adding useful notes, updating events, and fixing typos consistently all year.

Blog Author: PrimeraEspada91 & Xaphalys

Community member and chat moderator PrimeraEspada91 wins this section two years in a row!. His Monster Hunter World Guides have helped us on countless occasions, but his dedication to the Fextra community goes far deeper, providing Video Footage for Dark Souls Remastered and Death’s Gambit Walkthroughs, and detailed guides for Red Dead Redemption 2 and many other games. Thank you Primera!

Also please thank Xaphalys the dedicated and talented for her work to translate Fextralife articles into French!. Her translations have made it possible for our French-speaking users to get some content in their preferred language. Thank you Xaphalys!

It’s been a great year for gamers that featured a Souls Remaster, a God of War Re-Focusing, several awesome sequels and some amazing indies. You can check this list of 2019 games that we are excited about! You might also want to check out 2017’s winners.

Thoughts on our picks for this year’s awards? What were your favorite games of 2018? Do you think Sekiro will take all the awards next year? Be sure to let us know in the comments!

Visit the Fextralife Wikis Hub


MMO raider by day and guide writer by night, Fex enjoys multiplatform gaming, good books and animes, and streaming with a cold beer.

View my other posts

6 comments on “2018 Fexy Game Awards – Our GOTY 2018”

  1. Avatar mothereternity says:

    :> I don’t have a speech ready :>

    It makes it pretty easy to do what I do here because I love being a part of this community. I have been here for a long time now and it’s an amazing community to be a part of. I love helping people play, whether it be by editing wiki, providing links from wiki or being summoned into games to help.

    I also love the changes they made to multiplayer in ds:re and wish they had done it on sotfs.

    And I’ll have to take your word on red dead tho watching the streams was pretty fun.

    And im still stuck on whether to get elder scrolls….too many choices of new games.

  2. Anonymous says:

    Your article is very well written, I enjoyed a lot, I kind of disagree on the best multiplayer being DS remastered ’cause it was and still is a mess, such a cash grab and we knew as a community since the announcement it’d have failed and we were right; they haven’t fix any of the glitches and bugs that there were in the original and the multiplayer died miserably after a couple a months (sorry for the little rant, but seeing such a beloved and important game ruined by a lazy work is unacceptable). But, I’m so glad you choose Death’s Gambit as the best Souls-like ’cause is such a little game but does so much good (you should check Ashen as well). The best value is definately MHW, although there’s room for improvement it has been able to bring new players into this amazing world, and the updates are on points every time, many of the other companies should learn from them how to realease a "game as a service". In the end, it was a great year full of good games, looking forward to see if 2019 will top this year. Keep up the great job.

  3. Avatar elnawawi says:

    Again! For second year in row, Fex GOTY community choices are identical to my own in most categories. It’s a great joy to find a game site/journalist/community that capture the heart of RPG players, and pick choices to satisfy their feelings towards every year games.

    Great community, great choices, great promotions.. You deserve all respect for all hard work here, very well done!

  4. Avatar Castielle says:

    your comment gave me goosebumps. Our vision for the site has always been to find like-minded players that enjoy the sort of games that we play. To think that we might actually be accomplishing that on some level is a great feeling!


  5. ckmishn says:

    Unfortunately the PC version of Monster Hunter World has Denuvo (even if it has been cracked). Given how deep my game backlog is that’s enough for me to pass on any game that’s not part of a franchise I’m already a big fan of.

  6. Avatar qeter says:

    the @ function doesn’t show up on the blog formating, thought you would like to know that.

    I didn’t play MHW because it’s aesthetic is too distant from my own taste and I wouldn’t consider dks remastered to be relevant given that its just a lazy port. I didn’t know deaths gambit had dlc planned though i have read the patch notes on the two patches that came out since I finished it; good to hear the developer has long-term intentions of supporting the game.

Log in to leave a Comment